Writing

How to structure a business acquisition: price comes last

Headline price is rarely what anyone takes home. How I structure a business acquisition around cash at close, earnouts, and what the seller needs.

Roland Frasier9 min read

Part of: Deal structure

How do I structure a business acquisition? I settle the terms before I argue about the price. How much cash changes hands at closing? What gets paid later? What is conditional on performance? What rolls into equity? What protects each side if something goes wrong? These decisions determine what the deal is worth. The headline number becomes the easy part once the structure is right, because when I understand what the seller actually needs, I can build terms that get them there. Once you see that, you stop being afraid of the seller's number, because you know you can always meet the seller's price.

Why the headline number misleads everyone

The biggest thing people get wrong about deal structure in M&A is thinking the price is the deal. When you look at what you're going to get for your business, the consideration given at closing is not all cash. I've done more than 1,000 acquisitions and exits for myself and my clients over the years, and the headline is the number I trust the least. The only thing you know for sure you're going to get, the only thing you can count on, is the cash you receive at closing.

I'm going to walk you through how this looks from the seller's perspective, because it shows why this isn't about price. It's about terms.

Let's say private equity comes in and wants to buy your company, and their offer is $200 million. These offers are typically laid out in columns, so you'll see a column for the total value of the deal, and that will be $200 million. Is that going to show up as cash in the seller's hands when the deal closes? Absolutely not.

Inside that number, let's say part gets paid at close and $140 million is an earnout. The earnout has to happen for the seller to get that money. What do they have to do? They'll have to hit some sort of profit level, a gross revenue number, an employee retention target, a client retention target or something like that. So I start by taking that $140 million out of the $200 million, because I know it's not certain.

Then you have the cash at close, and you get into all the subcarvings there. Maybe 20% of that gets to the seller, so $12 million at closing. The rest depends on the clawbacks and the conditions. Maybe there's a condition that a certain number of customers have to move over to the new buyer's systems. Or maybe there's a rollover, which means the seller has to roll into the buyer's company. If they roll in, they have to acquire stock in the company that just bought them. Effectively, they're paying to buy into the company that bought their company, often at a much higher price than they got for theirs. There's a decent chance some of that $12 million gets clawed back, so maybe they end up with $6 million.

That's how you turn a $200 million offer into $6 million in cash. Watch out.

Buyers use the same levers

Every one of those tiny moving parts is a structure decision, and as a buyer, I use the exact same tools. This is simply splitting the consideration into cash at closing and other buckets, and that's really what we're doing. It's a great way to reduce the cash we have to come out of pocket with at closing. If we want to adjust those numbers up or down, we can move the deal around, because this works for almost any deal.

What's the difference between good structure and bad structure? To me, the difference is intent. I don't want to do deals where somebody is a loser and somebody is a winner. I want to do deals with a structure I've created that allows both people to get what they wanted from the transaction.

That's why we teach no money out of pocket deals as opposed to no money down deals. In almost every deal, even the ones we do, we still pay some cash at closing. It's really hard to find a good deal where the seller is completely comfortable taking nothing when the deal closes. So we use strategies that let the business pay for itself and give the seller cash at close, but that cash isn't coming from our pocket.

Start with what the seller will do with the money

Before I talk about price, I want to know why they're selling. Is it desperation? Are they chasing an opportunity, or do they just need cash right now? Each of those calls for a different structure.

Then there's the question of what they're going to do with the money. That's a really important conversation, because it tells me how flexible they'll be and it drives the creative structuring. My rule is that I only give them the cash they actually need now, and everything else gets pushed down the road.

It's just the sequence. Empathize with where they are, future pace them into life after the sale, find out what they want and need, and the offer structures itself, because nothing you've offered conflicts with what they wanted. You never shift out of the conversation into a pitch.

Lead with the price, then peel back the layers

Once we get into the numbers, I move into what I call the onion style of negotiating. We start with the one thing we know we need to negotiate, which is price, and we talk about it as little as possible. We peel back the layers only as we need to, because every detail you give them early on becomes something they can argue about.

Sometimes the seller isn't operating in reality about value. When that happens, I don't argue. I educate. Businesses sell for a multiple of profit, and I show comparable transactions so the number rests on the market instead of my opinion. To see how much a small change in profit moves that number, do the math on one margin point and the multiple.

Here's why price can come last. Take a super extreme example. If I can get loose enough terms, I could fund almost any acquisition over a million years. Nobody lives that long, so that's not a real offer, but it shows how this works. Because price and terms trade against each other, if I stretch the terms, the price becomes possible.

Collaborate instead of negotiating

The best structures come from sitting on the same side of the table, asking what the seller wants and what life looks like after this transaction, then building toward that. The rest is reciprocity and the trade between price and terms.

It also helps to be in the market for a deal without ever having to have one, because then you're operating from want instead of need. If you're operating from need, you'll take bad deals. You have to take them. If you're operating from want, you don't have time pressure, so you'll only do the right deals.

The terms that matter more than price

These are the structure points I look at and watch the most.

Earnouts. When you're structuring earnout deals, remember that you'll be paying them back with "post tax dollars." Corporate tax takes its share of the profit first, so you can't promise a full year's profit as an earnout payment. Most buyers miss this.

Equity rollover. Private equity buyers want to sell you the idea that what you keep will be worth more than what you're selling. The standard version is, hey, the 20% you'll continue to own after we buy the business will be worth more than the 80% you're selling. I've watched that go to zero over and over, so don't count on getting a second bite.

Put and call options. If it's based on a multiple of EBITDA, you want a floor. Here's how I know. We had a put and call based on a multiple of EBITDA with no floor, and when the pandemic happened and everything went to zero, we got zero from the buyout.

Carve outs. In real estate, when you buy a property, it's called fee simple ownership, and it's described as a bundle of rights. You have the rights to air, water, minerals, usage and all those things, and you can sell those separately. The same goes for businesses. A lot of times, buyers will say, I'm just after this one particular thing your business has, and everything else we're going to shut down. If you can identify what they want, what they don't care about and what's worth nothing to them, you can very often carve out the things they don't want without taking anything less for the business than you would have otherwise. We once sold only a URL, a trademark, a back catalog and a customer list, and we got almost 2x the multiple of the original offer.

Make your money on the buy

You'll hear that you make your money when you buy. That's true in stocks, it's true in real estate, and it's true in acquisitions. So how do we build wealth? We do it through entry terms.

My favorite is the 1x deal. Say it's a business with $360,000 in profit, and I can buy it at a 1x multiple. That means the purchase price is $360,000, so I get 100% of what I paid back after the first 12 months, and everything after that is profit. For these businesses, the multiple is typically between one and five times, so I'm always looking for that 1x deal.

Know who is paid on the headline

For the broker, the fee is paid on the total consideration, not just the cash at closing. Keep that in mind when you're shaping a deal with less cash up front. It's a good thing to have in your pocket.

Sellers need to understand their own math too. Their gain is the gross proceeds from the sale minus transaction expenses minus their basis, whatever that basis is. The basis might be the money they put in to get started or earnings they've already paid taxes on. Then the structure determines what actually lands in their pocket. That's really important for them to understand, which is why I show sellers the full picture, not the headline.

Putting it together

When you structure a business purchase, the price is just the label on the box. The cash at close, the conditions, the tax treatment, the floors and the carve outs decide what the deal really pays. More of the value usually sits in those terms than in the number itself, which is why the money isn't in the business, it's around it.

If you're structuring an acquisition and want a second set of eyes on the terms before you talk price, work with me.

Adapted from Roland's teaching in his Acquisitions and Exits coaching, and this video.

Common questions

What does it mean that price is the last thing you negotiate in an acquisition?
It means I settle the terms first: cash at closing, deferred payments, earnouts, rollover equity and protections like a floor. Price and terms trade against each other. Once I know what the seller actually needs, I can stretch or reshape the terms to reach their number. That makes the price the easiest part of the deal.
Why does cash at closing matter more than the headline price?
Cash at closing is the only money that is guaranteed. Everything else depends on conditions such as profit targets, revenue, employee retention, client retention, customer transfers or clawbacks. A $200 million offer can be structured so that only 6 million in cash ends up in the seller's hands.
What do buyers overlook when they structure an earnout?
Earnouts are paid back with post tax dollars. Corporate tax comes out of the business's profit before anything is available for the earnout, so you cannot promise a full year's profit as an earnout payment. Build the earnout around what the business can really pay after tax.
How do you find out how flexible a seller will be on terms?
Ask them what they are going to do with the money. Their reason for selling and their plans for the proceeds show how much cash they really need now and how much can be pushed down the road. Their answer shapes the whole structure.
Should a seller count on rolled equity being worth more later?
Not without protection. Private equity buyers often pitch that the 20% you keep will be worth more than the 80% you sold, and I have watched that go to zero repeatedly. If equity or a buyout option is part of the deal, negotiate a floor so a bad year cannot wipe out your price.